Verdict up front: Pick Superhuman if you live in your inbox, want the fastest keyboard-first client, and need Outlook as well as Gmail — and you are willing to pay $30 a month with no free plan. Pick Shortwave if you are on Gmail only, want AI that searches and reasons across years of your mail history, and want to start free or at $18 a month. Speed is Superhuman’s product; search is Shortwave’s.
Bottom line: Superhuman charges a premium for triage speed and polish. Shortwave charges less for an AI assistant that treats your whole inbox as a searchable memory — but only if that inbox is Gmail.
Superhuman vs Shortwave at a glance
| Feature | Superhuman Mail | Shortwave | Pick |
|---|---|---|---|
| Email providers | Gmail / Google Workspace and Outlook / Microsoft 365 | Gmail / Google Workspace only | Superhuman |
| Free plan | None | Yes — limited AI, 90 days of search history, 15 threads per AI search | Shortwave |
| Entry paid plan | Starter $30/member/month, or $25 billed annually | Pro $18/seat/month | Shortwave |
| Higher tiers | Business $40/month, or $33 billed annually; Enterprise custom | Business $30, Premier $45, Max $120 per seat/month | Depends on AI usage |
| Standout strength | Keyboard-first speed, split inboxes, read statuses, scheduling | AI search across years of mail, AI filters, personalised AI writing | Superhuman for speed; Shortwave for search |
| Advanced AI | Ask AI, Auto Drafts and CRM integrations are on Business, not Starter | Scales by tier — more AI usage, longer search history, more AI filters | Read the tier fine print on both |
| Billing | Monthly or annual (annual is cheaper) | Monthly billing only on current published plans; no annual discount listed | Superhuman for annual savings |
What does each one actually do?
Superhuman is a standalone email client built around speed: keyboard shortcuts for almost everything, split inboxes that separate important mail from the rest, snooze and reminders, read statuses, and built-in scheduling. AI is layered on top for drafting and summarising. Our Superhuman review covers whether that speed is worth $30 a month for an individual.
Shortwave is a Gmail client built around an AI assistant. Its headline feature is search that reads across your mail history and answers in context, pulling from many threads at once, alongside AI filters that sort incoming mail automatically and AI writing that adapts to your voice. Our Shortwave review looks at that search in detail.
What the pricing page doesn’t make obvious
Superhuman’s most-advertised AI is not on its cheapest plan. Starter at $30 a month ($25 annually) gets you the fast client and standard AI, but Ask AI, Auto Drafts, custom auto labels, the Mail MCP and HubSpot / Salesforce / Pipedrive integrations sit on Business at $40 a month ($33 annually). There is also a naming trap if you shop the wider Superhuman suite: the suite’s $12-a-month Pro tier includes Grammarly, Docs and the Go assistant, but it does not include the Mail app — Mail only arrives at suite Business. Price the standalone Mail Starter seat before assuming the cheaper suite tier gives you the inbox.
Shortwave’s catches are different. Its free plan stamps a “Sent with Shortwave” signature on outgoing mail and limits AI search to 90 days of history and 15 threads per search. Paid plans are billed monthly only, with no annual discount to soften the top end — and that top end is steep: Max is $120 a seat a month for the highest AI usage, unlimited search history and 50 AI filters. Teams also have to sit on the same plan, so one heavy user can pull a whole team’s price up.
Which is better for a heavy inbox?
If your problem is volume you must clear every day — hundreds of messages, lots of scheduling, lots of follow-ups — Superhuman’s triage speed, split inboxes and read statuses are built exactly for that, and its scheduling overlaps with tools people otherwise buy separately; compare that side of your workflow in our Calendly vs Cal.com comparison. If your problem is finding and using what is already in your mail — “what did we agree with that client in March?” — Shortwave’s AI search across 3 years of history on Pro, 5 years on Business and unlimited on Premier is the feature Superhuman does not match.
Which should you pick?
Pick Superhuman if you use Gmail or Outlook, process a heavy inbox daily, value keyboard speed and read statuses, and will actually use the Business-tier AI — budget $40 a month, not $30, if Ask AI and Auto Drafts are why you are buying it.
Pick Shortwave if you are Gmail-only, want to start free, care most about AI search over your history and automatic AI filters, and are comfortable with monthly-only billing. Start on Pro at $18; move up only when you hit its AI usage or search-history limits.
Pick neither if you need Outlook support at a low price or a free plan with no signature on outgoing mail — in both cases your current Gmail or Outlook app plus its built-in AI may be enough.
Frequently asked questions
Is Superhuman free?
No. Superhuman Mail has no free plan. Starter is $30 per member per month, or $25 billed annually, and Business is $40, or $33 billed annually.
Is Shortwave free?
Yes, Shortwave has a free plan with limited AI usage, 90 days of search history and 15 threads per AI search. Paid plans start at Pro, $18 a seat per month, with a 14-day free trial on paid tiers.
Does Shortwave work with Outlook?
No. Shortwave is Gmail and Google Workspace only. Superhuman supports both Gmail and Outlook / Microsoft 365, which is the deciding factor for many Microsoft shops.
Which AI features need Superhuman Business?
Ask AI, Auto Drafts, custom auto labels, the Mail MCP and CRM integrations with HubSpot, Salesforce and Pipedrive are Business-tier features. Starter includes the client and its standard AI, but not those.
Does Shortwave offer annual billing?
Its current published plans are billed monthly only, with no annual discount listed. Superhuman, by contrast, is cheaper on annual billing — $25 vs $30 a month on Starter.

