✉ The Friday AI Brief: the week's 5 best AI stories, tools & comparisons — in your inbox every Friday morning.

OpenAI logo

Congress Probes the Justice Department for Backing OpenAI in the Landmark AI Copyright Case

Twelve Democratic members of Congress wrote to the US Department of Justice on Thursday demanding to know why it intervened on OpenAI’s side in the New York Times copyright lawsuit — the first time the US government has ever weighed in on an AI-training copyright case. Why it matters: the lawmakers say the DOJ backed OpenAI without consulting the government’s own copyright experts, and they want to know whether outside companies influenced the filing.

November 19, 2026

What happened

The letter, led by Representatives Chellie Pingree of Maine, Becca Balint of Vermont and Deborah Ross of North Carolina, accuses the Justice Department of supporting OpenAI in the case without first consulting the federal government’s intellectual property agencies — the US Copyright Office and the US Patent and Trademark Office. Skipping that consultation, the representatives wrote, raised “serious questions about potential bias,” pointing to reporting that both agencies were surprised by the department’s filing.

The lawmakers also asked for more information about any “external companies and organizations” that may have influenced the DOJ’s decision to file. Spokespeople for the Justice Department, the Copyright Office, the USPTO and OpenAI did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the letter, and a New York Times spokesperson declined to comment.

The filing at the center of it

In September, the DOJ filed a brief supporting OpenAI that argued AI training is generally fair use. It was the first time the US government had taken a position in an AI-training copyright case — and, the lawmakers noted, the Trump administration had previously said these issues should be left to the courts. This is not the first pushback from the House: a separate group of Democratic representatives on the House Judiciary Committee criticized the filing in a court brief in October, arguing the department had injected its views contrary to its standard practice and without input from the federal bodies with actual expertise on the subject.

The case underneath

The Times sued OpenAI and Microsoft in 2023, accusing them of using millions of newspaper articles without permission to train ChatGPT. The case is the most prominent of dozens of lawsuits brought by copyright holders against AI companies including OpenAI, Anthropic and Meta over training data. Most of them will likely turn on the same question: whether training on copyrighted work counts as fair use because the resulting systems create new, transformative content. OpenAI has told the court that using copyrighted work for AI training is among the most transformative uses imaginable, while the Times argues OpenAI exploits its journalism to build competing content.

Why it matters

A government brief does not decide a case, but judges read them — and a fair-use ruling in the Times case would set the terms for every AI company that trains on published work. If Congress now forces the DOJ to explain who it talked to before filing, the politics around that brief get harder to ignore, whichever way the court eventually rules. For readers, the practical stakes are simple: the outcome helps decide whether AI assistants keep training on the open web’s journalism for free, or whether licensing becomes a permanent cost of building them — the “everything AI, tested” question of who pays for the content these models learn from.

Frequently asked questions

What did the DOJ file in the OpenAI copyright case?

In September, the Justice Department filed a brief supporting OpenAI, arguing that training AI systems on copyrighted material is generally fair use. It was the first time the US government had weighed in on an AI-training copyright case.

Why are lawmakers objecting now?

The 12 representatives say the DOJ filed without consulting the US Copyright Office or the Patent and Trademark Office — the government’s own intellectual property experts — and they want to know whether external companies or organizations influenced the filing.

What is the New York Times suing OpenAI over?

The Times’ 2023 lawsuit accuses OpenAI and Microsoft of using millions of its articles without permission to train ChatGPT. The case is expected to turn on whether AI training qualifies as fair use.

Sources: Reuters

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get the 5 best AI tools every week

Top AI news, tools, and prompts — one short email. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

Run a newsletter of your own? Monetize and grow it with SparkLoop →

Scroll to Top