✉ The Friday AI Brief: the week's 5 best AI stories, tools & comparisons — in your inbox every Friday morning.

The Abraham A. Ribicoff Federal Building and United States Courthouse in Hartford, Connecticut

A Federal Judge Says an Expert’s AI Prompts Are Not Private — They Are Part of Her Method

What happened: A US federal judge ruled on Friday, November 20 that an expert witness in a climate lawsuit against a Shell Oil subsidiary must turn over details of her use of AI — including the prompts used to produce her witness report. US District Judge Vernon Oliver in Connecticut held that the prompts are part of “the basis” for the expert’s opinions, not private draft notes. Why it matters: if you use AI to do the analytical work behind expert testimony, a court can now order you to show exactly what you asked it.

Connecticut — November 20, 2026

What the judge decided

Judge Oliver’s ruling affirms an earlier decision by a federal magistrate judge in the same case. The expert, Naomi Oreskes, prepared a witness report for the plaintiff, Conservation Law Foundation, in its lawsuit against Shell Oil Products US and other defendants. Oreskes or her team used AI prompts to sort through large numbers of documents. Oliver said those prompts comprise “the basis” for her opinions, and that they are distinguishable from notes related to draft material that might otherwise be shielded from disclosure.

The underlying lawsuit alleges that Shell’s terminal in New Haven, Connecticut risks exposing nearby neighborhoods and waterways to hazardous chemicals during flooding. Shell has denied wrongdoing. Neither Conservation Law Foundation nor Oreskes immediately responded to requests for comment on the ruling, and Shell did not immediately respond either. The case is Conservation Law Foundation Inc v Shell Oil Products US et al, US District Court for the District of Connecticut, No. 3:21-cv-00933-VDO.

Why courts are drawing this line

Reuters notes the decision is part of a growing number of disputes over whether and when an expert witness must disclose AI prompts. The logic is hard to argue with: an expert’s methodology has always been fair game in litigation, and if AI prompts are the tool that selected and filtered the evidence the expert relied on, the prompts are part of that methodology. Reuters also points out the practical consequence — requiring disclosure of AI-assisted research opens new avenues for opposing parties to argue that an expert’s analysis is flawed or unreliable, because the other side can now examine, and challenge, the exact instructions given to the model.

Why it matters

This is the kind of ruling that quietly changes professional behavior far beyond one climate case. Lawyers, consultants and expert witnesses who use AI to cull documents or shape analysis now have a clear signal from a federal court: keep your prompts, because you may have to produce them. The safe working assumption is no longer “the AI work is invisible” — it is “the AI work is discoverable.” Everything AI, tested — now including, apparently, under oath.

Frequently asked questions

What did Judge Oliver order?

He ruled that expert witness Naomi Oreskes must turn over details of her AI use, including the prompts used to produce her witness report for Conservation Law Foundation in its lawsuit against Shell Oil Products US, affirming a federal magistrate judge’s earlier decision.

Why aren’t the prompts protected as draft material?

Oliver said the prompts Oreskes or her team used to sort through large numbers of documents comprise “the basis” for her opinions, and are distinguishable from notes related to draft material that might otherwise be shielded from disclosure.

What is the underlying lawsuit about?

Conservation Law Foundation alleges that Shell’s terminal in New Haven, Connecticut risks exposing nearby neighborhoods and waterways to hazardous chemicals during flooding. Shell has denied wrongdoing.

Does this affect anyone besides expert witnesses?

The ruling is about expert-witness discovery, but it is part of a growing number of court disputes over AI use in litigation, and it signals that AI-assisted analytical work product may be treated as methodology — and therefore discoverable — rather than private drafting.

Sources: Reuters

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get the 5 best AI tools every week

Top AI news, tools, and prompts — one short email. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

Run a newsletter of your own? Monetize and grow it with SparkLoop →

Scroll to Top