Quick verdict
Billy Review 2026: COI Tracking and Prequalification Built Only for Construction
Updated November 20, 2026 – Tested Intelligence
Quick verdict: Billy is a construction-only compliance platform that collects and checks subcontractor certificates of insurance, W-9s, licenses, lien waivers and warranties in one place, with an AI review assistant flagging missing endorsements before a sub starts work. Self-Service starts at $500 a year, subs pay nothing and need no login, and a Managed tier hands the chasing to Billy’s own reviewers. It is a sharp fit for general contractors drowning in COI email; it does nothing for firms outside construction.
What it is
Billy, at billyforinsurance.com, is built exclusively for construction, unlike general COI tools that also serve real estate and retail. A general contractor sets insurance requirements by project or trade, Billy requests the documents automatically, and vendors or their brokers upload through a secure link with no account to create. Its AI review assistant reads each certificate and flags deficiencies against your requirements, including additional-insured endorsements such as CG 20 10 and CG 20 37. The same hub covers vendor prequalification questionnaires, certified payroll collection, W-9s, lien waivers and closeout warranties, so compliance runs from before the bid to years after final payment.
Key features
- AI certificate review: automated checking of COIs against project requirements, with endorsement validation and deficiency flags
- Automated collection: requests, expiration reminders and follow-ups go out without your team chasing email threads
- No-login uploads: subcontractors and their brokers submit through a secure link; subs never pay and never create an account
- Prequalification: online questionnaires you review and approve in the same place you track COIs
- More than COIs: W-9s, business licenses, certified payroll, lien waivers and warranties collected alongside insurance
- Procore depth: compliance status inside Procore, project and vendor sync, and Procore Pay blocking for non-compliant vendors
- Warranty tracking: follow-ups continue for a 2, 5 or 10-plus year warranty period after a project completes
- Managed option: CRIS-certified human reviewers handle review and deficiency resolution for you
- ERP integrations: Autodesk, CMiC, Sage, JD Edwards, Viewpoint Vista, ProjectSight and Acumatica
Pricing
Billy prices per vendor contract, billed annually. Self-Service, where your team runs compliance with automated requests, reminders and tracking, starts as low as $500 a year, and the per-vendor cost falls as volume rises. Managed, where Billy’s team requests, reviews and chases every document, is custom-priced by volume on a call. A one-time onboarding charge covers data import, requirement templates and team training; ask about broker or carrier partner pricing if one applies. There is no free plan.
What the pricing page doesn’t make obvious: the free trial is unusually concrete. On Billy’s own demo page it covers up to 25 vendor contracts with full dashboard, reminder and expiration access, and no credit card. Billy will also load your vendor list before the sales call and hand you a gap report showing every expired, missing or non-compliant certificate, yours to keep even if you do not buy. That makes the trial a real audit of your current exposure, not a sandbox.
Who it’s for
General contractors, home builders, owners and specialty contractors who work with subcontractors and vendors, from a roofer with a handful of subs to GCs tracking thousands of vendor contracts. Kitchell, for example, moved roughly 600 vendor contracts onto the Managed plan. Teams on Procore get the most, because compliance status and payment blocking live inside the system they already open.
Who should skip it
Anyone outside construction should skip it outright: Billy is construction-only by design, so a mixed portfolio of tenants, retail vendors and contractors needs a generalist tool or a second system. Very small firms with a few long-term subs they know personally may find a spreadsheet and calendar reminders enough until volume grows. And if you want the software to make the final compliance call with no human in the loop, note the honest split here: the AI flags deficiencies, but the Managed tier exists precisely because endorsement judgment is still human work.
Pros
- Construction-only design: project-based requirements, OCIP and CCIP wrap-ups and endorsement checks match how GCs actually work
- Published starting price ($500 a year) and a 25-contract, no-card trial, in a category that usually hides both behind a demo
- Subs pay nothing and need no login, which removes the biggest reason sub compliance stalls
- Warranty tracking keeps chasing insurance for years after closeout, where most COI tools stop at completion
- Procore Pay blocking turns a compliance flag into an actual payment hold instead of another ignored email
Cons
- Construction only: no use for non-construction vendor compliance
- Managed pricing is quote-only, so the hands-off version has no public number
- One-time onboarding is an extra cost on top of the annual plan
- Founded in 2021, so a shorter track record than long-running rivals such as myCOI
- Value depends on integrations: a GC outside its Procore and ERP list gets a thinner product
FAQ
How much does Billy cost?
Self-Service starts as low as $500 a year, priced per vendor contract and billed annually, with the per-vendor cost falling as you track more vendors. Managed, where Billy’s team does the requesting, reviewing and chasing, is custom-priced by volume. A one-time onboarding fee covers import, templates and training.
Do subcontractors have to pay or create an account?
No. Billy states subcontractors never pay, and vendors or their brokers upload documents through a secure link in the request email without creating an account or logging into a portal. That no-friction upload is a core part of the pitch.
Can Billy replace myCOI, Jones or TrustLayer?
Billy says yes, and that it imports your current vendors and certificates so you do not start from scratch. Setup usually takes about 45 minutes, with Billy handling the import. Whether it should replace them depends on fit: Billy’s edge is construction-only workflows, Procore depth and post-completion warranty tracking.
Bottom line
Billy is the focused pick in COI tracking: one construction-only hub for certificates, endorsements, W-9s, waivers and warranties, an AI assistant doing the first read, a published $500-a-year starting point, and tracking that continues through the warranty years when latent-defect exposure is still live. The trade is scope: it will never be your general vendor tool, and the fully managed version is priced in a conversation. For a GC whose compliance currently lives in one person’s inbox, that trade looks well worth making.

