Elon Musk’s SpaceXSI has filed its defence against a British lawmaker’s lawsuit over fake sexualised images of her created using the Grok AI platform, arguing that obviously fictitious, AI-generated content cannot breach someone’s right to privacy, Reuters reported on Thursday. Why it matters: the case is one of the first claims to test liability for the design of an AI system itself.
November 19, 2026
What is the lawsuit about?
Jess Asato, a member of Britain’s governing Labour Party who has publicly criticised both Musk and Grok, is suing after users generated sexualised images of her, including a video of her “being chloroformed and prepared for a sexual assault,” according to Reuters. Asato filed her lawsuit at London’s High Court for misuse of private information and breaches of data protection laws, alleging the way Grok was designed and trained enabled it to generate sexualised content. She is seeking a court order requiring SpaceXSI to “implement effective and permanent technical measures” to ensure Grok cannot create manipulated images of her. SpaceXSI says she is not entitled to such an order.
What does SpaceXSI argue?
In its written defence, dated October 29, SpaceXSI — part of Musk’s SpaceX, and formerly called xAI and then SpaceXAI — denies liability for any alleged breach of Asato’s privacy or data protection rights. Its lawyers said it had removed AI-generated images of Asato that breached its terms, including the chloroforming video. They argued, however, that other images it allowed to remain “would be understood by reasonable and sensible persons viewing that content to be AI-generated, fictitious and implausible … rather than as realistic images,” meaning Asato has no reasonable expectation of privacy. SpaceXSI also argues it did not breach her data protection rights, including because it “did not determine the content of the relevant users’ prompts.”
How did Asato respond?
Asato said in a statement on Thursday that those building powerful AI tools must take responsibility. “SpaceX SI wants to have it both ways,” she said. “The company admits it built the AI model, rewrote user requests to add its own graphic details, pulled images from across the internet, and published the results from an account it controls,” she said, adding: “Yet it also claims it is a neutral bystander without legal responsibility.”
Why it matters
The defence, in one of the first claims to test liability for the design of an AI system, could show how designers contest similar lawsuits, Reuters noted. Grok, distributed through X, is subject to regulatory probes in several countries after an outcry over its use to create non-consensual sexualised images. In mid-January, xAI said it restricted image editing in Grok, but Reuters found in early February that Grok continued to generate sexualised images even when users explicitly warned the subjects did not consent. The tested bottom line: “the images look fake” is now a formal legal defence for an AI maker — whether a court accepts it will shape accountability well beyond one platform.
Frequently asked questions
Who is suing, and where?
British Labour lawmaker Jess Asato is suing SpaceXSI at London’s High Court for misuse of private information and breaches of data protection laws.
What is SpaceXSI’s main argument?
That obviously fictitious, AI-generated content cannot breach a right to privacy, and that it did not determine the content of users’ prompts.
What outcome is Asato seeking?
A court order requiring SpaceXSI to implement effective and permanent technical measures to ensure Grok cannot create manipulated images of her.
Sources: Reuters

